In Jimmy Corrigan, The Smartest Kid on Earth, Chris
Ware emphasizes many problems with the United States and the need for a change.
He shows that America has grown away from connections between families,
resulting in the society crumbling. Through the parallelism with Jimmy Corrigan
and his grandfather James, Ware shows that a strained father son relationship,
obviously being problematic, has changed for the worst into a non-existent
relationship between Jimmy and his father. Ware feels that when America faces
challenges, rather than facing them appropriately, instead the results turn
worse. He argues that there is no hope for America and that there is no way to
improve upon the state of our society.
It is obvious that
Ware is unhappy with the current state of America. He shows through many of his
images the landscape as barren, offering no sense of happiness. One such example
is towards the beginning of the graphic novel when Jimmy is travelling on the
airplane. He looks out the window to see a Midwest farmhouse. Ware paints the
images in cool colors such as light green and blues representing the troubles
America currently has. This image occurs when Jimmy is travelling to Michigan
to meet his father. Ware’s choice of setting also shows the economic problems
of the United States. Michigan has not truly been economically successful since
the riots of Detroit in the 60’s. As Ware is trying to show, Detroit, like
America as a whole has only grown worse as the years have passed.
Ware creates an
interesting parallelism that emphasizes his take on America’s demise. He
believes that rather than improving on our problems, instead our country is
going downhill. He does this by emphasizing the relationship between father and
son for two different generations. Ware introduces the story of Jimmy’s
grandfather, James, early in Jimmy’s story. James’ father, Jimmy’s
great-grandfather, is an abusive man, consistently calling him a “son of a
bitch,” and criticizing him for everything he does. At one point while visiting
his sick grandmother, James runs away from home. In a series of images, he
hides under a bridge as its raining. The words across the frames say, “Maybe/
if this boy / could briefly glimpse, the life which awaited him/ as an adult /
he might be able to set aside his fears of his father/ And then rise
Confidently / and walk home.” Ware is describing the fact that if people
realized the future they could give to America, then perhaps they could make
the change now that the future needs. Instead, people cannot move past the
struggles of today and instead never change the world for the better.
As the story of
James and his abusive father continues, the story of Jimmy meeting his father
parallels it. Jimmy’s father left him and his mother when he was a child and he
has never known him. Ware suggests that perhaps it is worse to not know one’s
father at all, than have an abusive one. Jimmy’s efforts in getting to know his
father show Jimmy’s awkward social tendencies and incapability of communicating.
Ware shows that without the bond of family, or specifically without the
presence of a father, society has become unsuccessful. Ware shows through the
generations the initial relationship of a destructive father with a sufficient
son to an inexistent relationship between a generic father and an incapable
son. The relationship can be used to show the relationship between changes in
America. Ware feels that our country will continue to fall and can never
rebuild itself after the destruction of the family bond. He feels that because the
state of family interaction has fallen so much, so has the society in which we
live in.
Ware continues to
show the demise of America and the lack of hope for the future by using the
motif of Superman. Superman, like other superheroes, represents hope and a
sense of protection. However, Ware completely turns this idyllic view around to
show Superman as the opposite of a superhero. The motif is first seen in the
beginning of the novel. A young Jimmy and his mother go to a car show where “Super-Man”
is making an appearance. Jimmy is thrilled to meet the hero and see him in his
greatness. Instead, the faux-hero hits on his mother and returns home with her
for a one night stand. He is shown as not a hero at all, but someone who
manipulates women to sleep with him. The next occurrence of the motif is when
an adult Jimmy looks out his window to see a man dressed as Superman jump off a
building, committing suicide. Rather than the hero saving the world, he gives
up and leaves everyone helpless. Ware shows the need for a hero through the
stories of Jimmy and his great grandfather; he then undermines that need with
the complete uselessness of Superman, showing that no one, not even a “hero”
can save America. There is ultimately no hope for the future.
The future of
America has always been a subject heavily debated. Some people even go as far
as Ware to say there is no way of improvement; we can only go downhill. Ware’s vision
of the future can be most easily represented by one single image. When Jimmy is
getting a snack at work, Ware chooses to zoom in on the vending machine. The
image shows the word “change” with an arrow pointed downwards. Ware is
literally showing that the change happening is for the worse, proving there is
no way to improve our current situation. While Ware makes valid points that
America has problems, I think he lacks to see a wider view of the future. His
abysmal view of our country gives the novel a depressing tone that never
improves through the course of the story. By living life this way, it is sure
that the future will be worse than the present. I choose to look at life from a
more optimistic view. If I know that I will be able to make a difference in the
future, then I will be more successful than accepting that there is no hope for
the future. While I do not know the course of the future, I choose to hope for
the best and do my best to improve society.
I think you did a great job of explaining the parallelism between the two generations of the Corrigan family. You also did a great job of interweaving it with the hopelessness Ware has towards America. There is no hope to improve, because when we are faced with challenges, we take the easy route and avoid it instead of genuinely trying to fix it or improve. I like that you pointed out America worsening with depression and economic crises and how it’s seeping into family life as well, throughout multiple generations. The family bond is being destructed. Ware is expressing his unhappiness towards America through Jimmy and the role he’s playing.
ReplyDeleteYou also do a great job of explaining the various symbols Ware uses to represent this fall of society, such as Superman giving up by committing suicide. I also liked that you pointed out the word “change” with downward arrows on the vending machine. That’s something I completely overlooked and would not have noticed if you hadn’t pointed it out. I think this relates to what we discussed in class. The McDonalds icon represents convenience and since thousands of McDonalds restaurants are located across America, it can be said that America is becoming a country of lost hope. It is moving towards an age of convenience and sub-par work. I would like to see you go further into the symbols/icons Ware uses to enhance your argument. Reading the rest of the book, there are many more symbols that come up that you could further analyze.
I agree with the premise that in Ware, nihilism inside the family is never just about the family. However, even in the introduction I’d like to understand some of your reasoning, rather than just seeing the summarized argument. I agree, in general, with what you say about how America is drawn (where I’ll go in class next time is to the postcards right about halfway through the book), but you’re a little light on detail re: this subject in particular. The third paragraph is, at its heart, an interesting speculation - the argument could use a lot of detail if it’s an important part of what you’re doing.
ReplyDeleteThe details you zero in on about “Change” pointed down and the running satire of Superman (obviously an incarnation of America in some sense, as he always is - google “Superman” + “American Flag” + “image” sometime) are good. You probably should have led with some of this material, doing things in approximately the reverse order of what you actually did. You aren’t focused enough at the beginning - reversing the order would have helped a lot with that.
Ultimately the biggest absence here is a sense of *why* Ware finds America to be so hopeless. Without that, your response rings a little hollow. I’d argue that he finds that technological and economic “progress” has tended to atomize us, destroying connections and meaning while giving us more stuff, and that we are hopeless because we are isolated. That’s my take, and you don’t need to buy it - but having a vision of your own in place of that is vital.